Cash or accrual: which one fits a New Hampshire small business?
For most owner-run service businesses, cash is the simpler starting point, and accrual becomes the better tool once money starts moving on credit. IRS Publication 538 says most individuals and many small businesses use the cash method, and also that no single method is required of all taxpayers. Whatever you pick has to clearly reflect your income, and you have to use it the same way from year to year.
Picture a landscaper in Concord who sends a bill when the spring cleanup is done and gets paid within the week. Cash books tell that owner nearly everything. Now picture a gift shop owner in Burlington, Vermont, who buys stock in September for the holidays and sells most of it in December. That owner needs to see what's on the shelves and what's owed to suppliers, and cash books hide both until the money moves.
What's the actual difference between the two methods?
The difference is timing, meaning when a sale and a bill land in your books. Under the cash method, Publication 538 says you include income in the year you actually or constructively receive it, and you generally deduct expenses in the year you pay them. Under an accrual method, you generally report income in the year it's earned and deduct expenses in the year they're incurred.
One term trips people up. Constructive receipt means income counts as received once it's credited to your account or made available to you without restriction, even if you haven't touched it. Going by that definition, a payment already credited to your account in December counts as received in December on the cash method, even if you leave it untouched until January.
| What you're asking | Cash method | Accrual method |
|---|---|---|
| When a sale counts as income | When the money is received or made available | When it's earned |
| When a bill counts as an expense | When you pay it | When you incur it |
| What happens to unpaid customer invoices | They stay out of income until paid | They're already in income |
| What the monthly profit report shows | Money that moved in and out | Work done and costs owed |
| Who it usually suits | Businesses paid at the time of the job | Businesses that invoice on terms or hold stock |
When does the IRS push a business toward accrual?
Two parts of the rules matter for a small firm: inventory, and entity type. Publication 538 says that if you produce, purchase or sell merchandise, you generally must keep an inventory and use an accrual method for sales and purchases of merchandise. A small business taxpayer has an exception and can choose not to keep an inventory in the usual way, as long as the method it uses still clearly reflects income.
On entity type, the same publication lists who generally can't use the cash method: a corporation other than an S corporation, a partnership with one of those corporations as a partner, and a tax shelter. Most of those can still use cash if they meet the gross receipts test, which averages gross receipts over the three prior tax years against a limit the IRS indexes for inflation. A sole proprietor or an S corporation isn't on that list at all.
Whoever handles your tax preparation helps you apply those rules to your return. Your part is to tell them early whether you hold stock, invoice on terms, or have a corporate partner, so the question is asked before the first return is filed.
Not sure which method your books use?
Book a free consultation and talk through how your books count sales and bills today.
Which method suits which kind of business?
Match the method to how cash actually reaches you.
You're paid on the spot or within days
Cash usually fits. A Manchester cleaning company paid by card at the end of each visit has almost no gap between earning and collecting, so the books and the bank statement tell the same story. Watch the bills you prepay: Publication 538 says an expense paid in advance is generally deductible only in the year it applies to, unless it qualifies for the 12-month rule.
You invoice and wait a month or more to be paid
Accrual starts to earn its place here. A Nashua contractor with several open invoices can look broke in the bank and profitable on paper. Accrual reports put the open invoices in income already, which tells you whether the work made money, while the bank balance tells you whether you can cover payroll on Friday. You need both answers, and cash books only give you the second one.
You buy and sell stock
Expect accrual for purchases and sales, unless the small business taxpayer exception applies and you choose to use it. The publication also allows a hybrid method, a mix of cash and accrual, as long as the mix clearly reflects income and you use it consistently. In practice that often means accrual for the merchandise and cash for most other income and expenses.
You run two separate businesses
Two separate and distinct businesses can each use a different method, but the publication says no business counts as separate and distinct unless it keeps a complete and separate set of books and records. A landscaping business and a snow plowing sideline run out of one set of books count as one business here. Our guide to keeping business and personal finances separate covers the bank account side.
Does selling into Vermont change anything?
The federal method question is the same wherever you are, but state taxes add balances to track. The NH Department of Revenue Administration says there is no general sales tax on goods purchased in New Hampshire, so an owner selling goods only in the state has one less balance to watch. A shop registered to collect Vermont sales tax charges the 6% state rate the Vermont Department of Taxes gives on taxable retail sales, plus a 1% local option sales tax in towns that levy one, Burlington among them. The state page also says an out-of-state seller must register and collect once its Vermont sales reach a set sales or transaction threshold.
Whichever method you use, sales tax you collect is cleanest in its own liability account until it's paid to the state, so it never inflates your sales figure. For the rest of the state picture, our New Hampshire small business taxes guide walks through the Business Profits Tax and the Business Enterprise Tax.
Can you switch methods later?
Yes, but it isn't a setting you flip. Publication 538 says you choose an accounting method when you file your first tax return, and if you later want to change it you generally need IRS approval, which is requested on Form 3115. That's why the choice is worth making on purpose in year one rather than by default.
If the books were kept one way and the return filed another, or nobody is sure which method was used, sort the books out first and ask the tax question second. Catch-up bookkeeping is the place to start when the records themselves are behind or inconsistent.
What should you check this month?
- Look at last year's business return, or ask your preparer, which accounting method it used.
- Make sure your monthly profit report uses the same basis, or label it clearly when it doesn't.
- If you invoice on terms, review the list of unpaid customer invoices every month whichever method you use.
- Keep any sales tax you collect in its own liability account, separate from sales.
- If you hold stock, ask your preparer before year end how inventory should be handled.
If you'd rather hand the monthly side off, that's what monthly bookkeeping is for, and the chart of accounts guide shows how to lay out the accounts underneath it. Ledger House works with small businesses across the United States from offices in New Hampshire.




